|
What products quit smoking programs work best?
Study compares
Zyban, nicotine replacement
and a combination of both treatments
Combining the
nicotine patch
and the nicotine inhaler Two hits of nicotine are better than one if you want to quit smoking, new research shows. A French study suggests smokers may have a better chance to beat their bad habit with a nicotine inhaler and a patch instead of just an inhaler. At six weeks, 60.5 percent of those who used the combination had quit, while only 47.5 percent of those who used an inhaler alone had stopped, the study finds. At 12 weeks, the numbers were 42 percent and 31 percent, respectively. After a year, 19.5 percent using the combination had stayed quit, but only 14 percent who used the inhaler alone had remained smokefree. The study, conducted at the French National Institute of Health and Medical Research, appears in a recent issue of the Archives of Internal Medicine.
Nicotine Replacement
Therapy (NRT)
Patch, gum or inhaler? This Cochrane Review study done in 1996 and updated in November, 2007, found that nicotine replacement therapies like the patch, gum or inhaler increased chances of quitting by 50% to 70%. Bear in mind that with no program, only 5% of quitters are still smokefree at the end of 12 months. A 50% increase in the quit rate would mean that 7.5% of those using NRT were successful after 12 months.
Telephone support Call 1-800-QUIT NOW for free support with a trained counselor, who will talk to you whether you are ready to quit or just thinking about it. This number will forward to your State's tobacco cessation program, which offers live phone support in your area. When you call, a friendly staff person will offer a choice of free services, including self-help materials, a referral list of other programs in your community, and one-one-counseling over the phone. There is also the National Cancer Institute's Smoking Quitline, 1-877-44U-Quit, offering proactive counseling by trained personnel.
Aversion Therapy The Schick-Shadel Treatment Centers offer aversion therapy -- self-administering a mild electric shock from an ordinary 9 volt battery as one smokes a cigarette. Studies show a 95% initial success rate, and 50% after a year -- better than all the other programs! But most pharmaceutical companies today are reluctant to add an aversion therapy option to their helpful products. Sadly, they regard aversion therapy as being "not consumer friendly." The Foundation for a Smokefree America hopes that one company will soon get behind this important and proven method of qutting smoking.
Alternative therapies
Alternative therapies such as hypnosis, acupuncture and herbs have been shown to be far less effective than the above methods. Several controlled studies found they were ineffective.
Boilerplate Points
It's not enough simply to use a product. Counseling, and as well as utilizing the classic, boilerplate points for quitting, are critical to succeeding. Our Quitting Tips page includes a useful guide to these critically important boilerplate points. These will empower you with valuable techniques, and will also strengthen your motivation and resolve.
SELECTED QUITTING
RESOURCES
The
American Lung Association's
The venerable Mayo Clinic offers its Nicotine Dependence Center, including a very pricey in-patient program for quitting. They offer individual counseling, an 8-day residential program, and a work site program for companies. They report a success rate after one-year of 23 to 45 percent, depending on the program. That is well above the average. With locations in Arizona, Minnesota and Florida, this is perhaps the Rolls Royce of stop smoking programs. Another excellent inpatient program is offered, at St. Helena Hospital in Northern California's Napa valley. Or just call them at (707) 963-6360. You check in for a week, and it's not cheap! But the wealthy may need a bit of extra support in quitting, as they do not always have the strongest self-denial muscles. Are you able to easily put off getting a brand new car, or going to a $60 per head restaurant? How about postponing that vacation in Monte Carlo, Aspen, or Florida? If you can do those things, chances are you won't need an inpatient program, and you'll have all the self-denial muscles you'll need to quit smoking. But you'll need to flex them. And yes, it might hurt a bit.
At www.quitnet.org you can go to a chat room where those quitting are doing it together, not alone. It can be a great source of support -- like a Nicotine Anonymous meeting, but online. This site was put together by the Massachusetts Department of Public Health's Tobacco Control Program.
Laser treatment is a newly available method. It's for the adventurous; as of November, 2005, we know of no university studies published in mainstream medical journals which provide reliable data on their success rate 12 months after treatment. But with the patch and nicotine gum at an 85% failure rate after 12 months, it might be something to try. Freedom Laser Therapy's laser treatment claims to alleviate nicotine withdrawal symptoms. They also offer a 30 minute video on the psychological aspects of the addiction, and a 30 day vitamin detoxification regimen.
Also
check out these cool
youth-oriented QUITTING sites
The
opening animated page says it all -- YOU are
a target. But your mind is a weapon. "Question It" provides
tips to help smokers win their personal battle against tobacco.
|